Youth Soccer FAQ: The Questions Every Parent Has

(Or, this is why we created Chasing the Game.)

We started this podcast because we were asking the same questions as every other soccer parent. The youth soccer scene in America is complicated: leagues, costs, emotions, pressure, and dreams. Our kids live inside this game, and as parents, we often feel like confused consumers riding an emotional rollercoaster.

So we built Chasing the Game to learn together with the community—hearing directly from coaches, academy directors, parents, and players. These are the real questions that started it all, and the same ones millions of families search for every day.

Leagues, Pathways & the U.S. Soccer Structure

  • What’s the difference between MLS NEXT, ECNL, GA, and USYS—and which path fits my child?

  • Why is youth soccer in America so complicated?

  • Will joining a top academy boost development or college chances?

  • Is there a “right” age to move up to a more competitive league?

  • How do showcases, scouting, and international opportunities really work?

  • What are the realistic odds of going pro from the U.S.?

  • How does promotion and relegation abroad compare with what we have here?

  • Why does every club tell parents something different?

  • How should parents evaluate a new team or club?

Tryouts, Coaches & Player Evaluation

  • What are coaches actually looking for at tryouts?

  • Should parents talk to the coach before or after tryouts?

  • What matters most at this age: skill, athleticism, effort, or decision-making?

  • How do playing time and positions impact long-term growth?

  • When is it time to switch clubs, and when is it better to stay?

  • What does healthy communication between parents and coaches look like?

Costs, Travel & the Business of Youth Soccer

  • Why is youth soccer so expensive across all levels?

  • Are MLS academy programs truly free?

  • What are families really paying for each season?

  • Does spending more lead to better development or opportunities?

  • Is private training necessary, or is it just pressure from the system?

Development, Training & Player Mindset

  • How often should kids train each week?

  • Should players specialize early or play multiple sports?

  • How do we help kids handle nerves, pressure, and mistakes?

  • How do parents approach the car-ride home conversation in a healthy way?

  • When should kids start fitness or strength training?

  • How do we build resilience without burning kids out?

Parents, Sidelines & Behavior

  • Why do sideline emotions run so high for parents?

  • What does positive support during a match look like?

  • How much should parents communicate with coaches—and when?

  • What is the purpose of the 48-hour rule?

  • How do families manage team drama, politics, or parent dynamics?

Recreational, Travel & High School Soccer

  • When is recreational soccer enough, and when should kids move to travel?

  • Will my child fall behind if they start competitive soccer later?

  • Should high school soccer complement or conflict with club soccer?

  • What’s a realistic development timeline for kids at different ages?

College Recruiting & Scholarships

  • When should families begin considering the college soccer pathway?

  • Do ID camps actually benefit players, or are they mostly used for marketing?

  • How crucial are highlight videos and social media in recruiting?

  • What do college coaches truly look for in players?

  • How can kids get noticed without big-club connections?

Professional Pathways & Playing Abroad

  • Can American youth players realistically make it in European academies?

  • How do scouts discover players from the U.S. system?

  • What are the differences between going pro in MLS versus Europe?

  • How do players balance ambition with school, family, and mental health?

Why These Questions Matter

Every parent, coach, and player is trying to make sense of a fast-changing, high-pressure system. Chasing the Game exists to explore these questions with the people shaping youth soccer in America, making the path clearer, more honest, and more connected for every family navigating the game.

Ask better questions. Listen deeper. Learn together.

Hear the full stories on Chasing the Game now streaming on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and YouTube.

BACK TO HOME